He dug through the snow, ungloved. A full moon threaded through the bare branches of the maple and cast shadows on the bright snow.
Inside, she opened her fist; the ring had left a mark on her palm. It had belonged to a lot of dutiful wives before her–his mother, grandmother, and great-grandmother. She’d worn the ring, too, for most of their nineteen-year marriage. Except for the winter when she had excema between her fingers. Or the times when slipping it off during her mother-in-law’s visits gave her a private relief. She’d stopped wearing it altogether during her pregnancies because her fingers were too swollen. But when she finally put it on again, something had changed; the ring made her hand look like someone else’s. Sometimes, when she was chopping onions or folding laundry or rubbing a sick child’s back, she would pause, study her hand, and wonder whom it belonged to.
The husband must have sensed her ambivalence about the ring because he took her ring shopping for their fifteenth anniversary. They drove to a store with a glass atrium shaped like the sides of a point-cut diamond. When they stepped inside, the saleswoman greeted them without smiling.
“You’re due for an upgrade,” she whispered to the wife, who traced her hand absently along the glass case as she eyed ring after glittering ring.
“I wouldn’t know where to start.”
“You can start with the diamond or the setting,” suggested the saleswoman. The wife looked to her husband. “I recommend starting with the diamond,” said the saleswoman quickly, setting a velvet pillow on the glass and then unlocking the cabinet.
The husband drummed his fingers against the display glass.
“I wouldn’t how to choose,” she looked up at her husband. He shifted his weight.
“You will know,” assured the saleswoman. “It’s like choosing a puppy from a litter. One wins your heart.” She dumped a dozen diamonds from the pouch onto the velvet pillow and prodded them to sparkle with her white-tipped nails, as if they were horses needing cropping. She studied the wife’s face, and then used a metal file to set one diamond apart from the rest. It was not the largest diamond, but light rebounded from it as if it were a many-sided mirror.
“This is the one,” the saleswoman told the husband. “I wouldn’t have guessed the emerald cut. It’s unconventional. But that narrows down the settings.”
She flipped over a business card, scribbled something on it, then slid it across the glass to the husband. He looked it over and placed it in his wallet next to a stack of crisp bills.
“And here you are, my dear.” The saleswoman pinched the wife’s own ring between her pointer finger and thumb and waited for her to take it. “You can wear this until you get the new one.”
Weeks, then months, then more anniversaries plodded by without hint of the new ring. So the wife started taking off her old one at night to remind her husband. And it helped sometimes.
Once she left it carelessly on the window ledge above the kitchen sink. “What is your ring doing here?” He demanded, as if she had let the children out without mittens.
“I took it off to wash the dishes,” she said without looking up from her novel. “It’s a bit loose. I might need to have it resized.”
“Well, be careful with it. It’s a family heirloom, remember?”
“I haven’t lost a ring yet.” She glanced at him over the rim of her coffee cup.
“I think you are being snide.”
“Not at all.” She set the cup down and rubbed her finger over a small chip in the saucer. Her hand was trembling.
The husband had lost his wedding ring during their honeymoon to Looking Glass Falls. They had been hiking and stopped beneath the falls for a swim. She balanced on the slippery rocks and dipped her toes into the frigid water. He dove in. When he surfaced, he shook the water from his hair and hollered at her to join him. He swam to the deepest part of the plunge pool, where the water spilled over the rim of rocks. There, the water seemed black and impenetrable. When her husband dove under, she saw a sinking flash of flesh and then nothing at all. She grew worried and waded in up to her chest. Suddenly, he grabbed her leg and pulled her under. They surfaced, sputtering and laughing, until she noticed his naked finger. “Your ring!”
The husband borrowed a mask and snorkel from some kids who were diving for pennies. He dove time and again into that deep and infinite pool. She held her breath with him, for him, until he breached, blowing water, gasping and blue. Nothing. Nothing and nothing and nothing again. He returned to her, shivering. They had no words for what had happened. They had to cut their losses and move on.
Sometimes, when she woke in the night and lay in bed next to her husband, she imagined that lost ring, lodged between river rocks, beyond the reach of sunlight and the pounding of the falls.
He continued pawing through the snow, this time in the far corner of the yard.
Virgin snow covered the ground beneath the balcony door from which she had tossed the ring. Or pretended to. Now his footprints marred the snow as if their yard were a playground after recess. He hung his head. She almost called to him, “I have the ring. Come inside and warm up.”
He suddenly straightened and turned toward her, jaw clenched. She could see his eyes across the yard, round and white as the moon.
She withdrew from the window and tiptoed down the stairs so she didn’t wake the children. She hurried to the back door, and, holding the ring in her left hand, reached out with her right to lock it, just as he came to the door. They stared at one another through the glass. His nostrils flared and frosted the pane. Her own transposed reflection distorted the features of her husband’s face. Together, they had a grotesquely large nose, hollow cheeks, and cavernous eyes. He pounded on the door. She stumbled back and held the ring in the air, where it glittered like ice in the moonlight.
His eyes widened, then hardened. He bent over to scoop up a handful of snow and slam it against the glass.
She flung the ring into the room’s darkness where it pinged against the tile floor. Then she unlocked the door and raced up the stairs. Panting, she crawled into bed with their youngest child.
Their daughter lay sideways across the bed, her arms splayed across the mattress. The wife caught her daughter’s hand, warm and soft, and drew it to her chest. Thank goodness she has my hands, thought the wife.
She heard her husband’s heavy footsteps on the stairs. He paused in front of the boys’ room. She could hear him breathe. His measured footfalls continued down the hall. He stopped in front of their daughter’s door and pushed it open with his knuckles.
The wife pressed herself harder against her daughter’s warm body. Her husband stood in the doorway, a shadow. They stared across the room, as if they could see one another through the darkness. They had no words for what had happened. They had to cut their losses and move on.